Twitter has multiple business models to choose from
I get asked over and over: “How do you think Twitter will monetize? What’s their business model?” While it’s clear they’re already experimenting with ‘house’ ads, ads that promote features of their service, I’m not sure that’s going to be the right direction for them. We already know that click through rates on social networks are low, why? because people are there to communicate with each other –not search for information like Google or on a media site. It’s possible they could turn on ads in the search tool, as people are seeking information. Yet all of these tactics have been done on other social sites, I think that Twitter has a unique opportunity to tap into the lucrative CRM space.
Manually tracking a large brand within Twitter isn’t scalable
It’s important to first realize that managing a large brand on Twitter isn’t scalable, with hundreds –maybe thousands of tweets about a marketplace a day, individuals will have a very difficult time managing, Brian Solis has some relevant stats on growth. The next challenge? determining who these people are, and if they are a potential customer is important, who are these people, are they important, where do they live? Lastly, responding in near real time is going to be key –as some users may ask their peers for product recommendations during point of sale, right in the store.
Twitter has two of the three key features of a CRM system
First, let’s break down why Twitter is going to be a Social CRM, let’s start by analyzing what entails Customer Relationship Management:
1) Customers: Yes, they got that. More than that, they have prospects, which to some marketers is far more valuable. As prospects start to talk about products, they’re indicating engagement, and could be further down the buying process. Both are valuable, however the challenge is mapping which Twitter ID is which customer –many don’t use their real names.
2) Relationships: Got that too. Now I realize that the intended definitions of CRM meant the relationships between customers and employees of a brand, but now you can see how people in Twitter are connecting to each other, and those that follow a brand, their indicating affinity towards them. The interesting thing is they don’t just offer affinity towards your brand, but also competitors, which helps in segmenting your market, and can help with poaching.
3) Management: Here lies the opportunity Twitter has no management tools to support this, as a result, their data is being whisked away in the API and being aggregated by two types of companies. The first company? Traditional CRM companies are importing the data into their own systems, in fact we know bits and pieces of this are happening for Facebook. Secondly, brand monitoring companies like Radian6, are importing twitter data into their listening platforms, and then offering simple workflow and task management.
CRM Incumbents Moving In
Today, SalesForce announces it’s integration with Twitter, or at least, their aggregation of their data in what’s called the ‘Twitter Firehose’ in order to suck in the discussions and allow it to be managed within the SalesForce system. As a result, brands will start to monitor –then manage– the discussions that happen online. I was briefed by Clara Shih (related book), the creator of FaceForce (now called Faceconnector) (Facebook + SalesForce integration) last week, and while I think they’ve taken one step forward –there’s more to be done in confirming IDs, influence, and intent to buy. Update: Here’s the Service Cloud site, which emphasizes customer service and support.
Twitter’s Opportunity –should they decide to take it
Although they have not directly said it, I think Twitter can go further than this, they could be their own CRM system, by perhaps offering their own analytics system to brands, that will help them to track and manage the conversations within the 140 sphere. This has tremendous opportunities for Twitter should they create their own brand management system that they can resell to the world’s companies to monitor, alert, track, prioritize, triage, assign, followup, and report on the interactions with brands. The myriad of authority based tools will need to be incorporated, as some users have a larger network and are therefore more influential than others. On the other hand, they just might leave the firehose open for the incumbent CRM companies to take advantage of –and miss this opportunity, hell, Scoble is already expecting brands to contact him when he has a major life event. Either way, with a recent funding amount of $35mm, they’ve enough run rate to first manage growth, then prepare for monetization.
There are a few layers when it comes to how Social CRM can evolve, I’ll save that for a future post. On a related note, this is one of the key findings from our many interviews for the upcoming report: The Future of the Social Web.
with so many intelligent people throwing ideas at twitter, i don’t understand what’s taking them so long. this is crowd sourcing at its best and they seem to be missing the boat. this idea is smart, and there are others as well. just pick one and go with it.
When you write “their” you sometimes mean “they’re.”
“Their” is a possessive, indicating ownership – “their API” means “the API belonging to them.” It’s clear that you know this, as you use their correctly many times in the article.
“They’re” is a contraction of “they are.”
So “…their already experimenting with ‘house’ ads…” should be “…they’re already experimenting with ‘house’ ads…”
I wouldn’t have mentioned this, except that you made the same mistake twice in this article.
Hey there,
Great post! No wonder your post ranks #2 in the http://www.boilingpage.com which tracks the hottest web pages in recent tweets.
Congrats!
Twitter as one big commercial billboard? I’m already thinking of quitting Twitter by going cold twerky. Manipulating me via CRM will push me over the twedge.
Interesting post. You mentioned in the beginning, that people are on social networks rather to communicate, not to search information. This may indeed be one reason for the problems io social networks and marketing. But, is there any research/scientific reference yet, which supports this statement?
I don’t know anyone who twitters, is this just for 13 year olds with mobile bills they don’t have to pay?
Where is the sense in this ??
is it because i am 72 yrs old?
I’ve got twitter in my pants, and by that I mean it’s time to generate meaningless data with richer content than just “I™m eating eggplant and touching my left nipple” Twitter needs to strap a photograph/gps location/smell/ for the last 24 hours of someones life into an interactive map like google earth. Then finally the people of earth can stop functioning like normal humans and indulge in non stop narcissism.
Interesting post…I am not sure it is even worth classifying it as traditional CRM especially for Enterprises.
In the fear of stating the obvious…Social Media behaves more like Feedback System and gives us real time insight into what Customer is Experiencing or feeling in their own words. It is better than running analytics on historical Customer data and understanding Lifetime value scores for Real time decisiong…it also works better than the old school form of sending out surveys or questionnaires to understand how the Customer feels…This is because just by reading the tweets you exactly know what a Customer’s state of mind is like.
If they get it right…one interesting business model is Twitter could be the required cheapest CRM for the Longtail SMBs…and give the SaaS vendors a run for their money.
with so many intelligent people throwing ideas at twitter, i don't understand what's taking them so long. this is crowd sourcing at its best and they seem to be missing the boat. this idea is smart, and there are others as well. just pick one and go with it.
Twitter is part of a broader category of social marketing. A major trend that is very evident and will continue to increase is the use of social media to attract leads and potential customers. Tools such as Customer Relationship Management (CRM) put the customer in the center of daily operations and allow for a 360 degree view of the client. SocialCRM is a way to combine traditional front office processes (such as email marketing, lead qualification, forecasting, opportunity management, etc.) with social marketing avenues like Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.